DIY HR: A Guide for Small Businesses in 2026

Effective human resources helps small businesses support employees and achieve long-term growth and success. From hiring and onboarding to compliance and talent development, HR decisions influence how teams operate and how businesses scale. For many small- to medium-sized businesses (SMBs), however, building a dedicated HR department isn’t realistic.

As a result, many founders and operators turn to do-it-yourself (DIY) HR. While this can be an efficient and low-cost solution, the approach also comes with real risks. Compliance gaps, inconsistent processes, and time constraints can quickly create challenges as a business grows.

This guide explains what DIY HR is, what the core HR functions are, why some small businesses choose this model, and how to implement best practices that reduce risk, costs, and time spent on administrative tasks.

If you have an immediate need for HR support, consider engaging a skilled HR freelancer on Upwork. Upgrade to Business Plus to access the top 1% of freelancers on Upwork and an AI-guided hiring experience — which can help you go from job post to project start within a matter of hours.

What is DIY HR?

DIY HR refers to when human resources functions are managed internally, rather than outsourced.

In many cases, small businesses lack the budget or headcount to hire a dedicated human resources professional, meaning DIY HR is handled by the founder or another leader who oversees multiple responsibilities across the business. In fact, a 2025 survey distributed by OnPay featuring insights from more than 1,000 small business owners found that 66% take on HR tasks without help — an increase from 55% in 2024. 

Small businesses may opt for DIY HR for several reasons, such as:

• Cost savings. Outsourcing HR or hiring a dedicated human resources leader may not be financially feasible, especially in the early stages of growth.
• Desire for control. Small business owners and founders often want to stay closely involved in hiring decisions, company culture, and people management.
• Gradual approach to scaling HR. Some small businesses prefer to build HR processes over time, adding structure as their workforce grows rather than implementing formal systems early on.
• Uncertainty around long-term workforce plans. When future hiring needs for growing businesses are unclear, owners may choose to manage HR internally until they have better visibility into growth and staffing requirements.

Core HR functions

Even in the absence of a formal HR department, small businesses are responsible for a range of HR functions. 

Typical HR functions include: 

• Recruitment and hiring. HR includes identifying workforce needs, writing job descriptions, sourcing candidates, screening applicants, and making recruitment and hiring decisions that align with business goals and budgets.
• Onboarding. Effective onboarding ensures new hires or contractors have the tools, documentation, and information they need to succeed, while also setting clear expectations from day one.
• Strategic workforce planning. Beyond filling open roles, strategic HR and workforce planning involves planning for future skills, capacity needs, and organizational structure to support long-term growth and changing business priorities.
• Payroll, compensation, and benefits administration. This involves managing wages, contractor payments, payroll taxes, and deductions, as well as administering benefits such as health insurance, paid time off, and other perks. Accurate and timely payroll and benefits administration supports compliance, employee trust, and overall engagement.
• Compliance and labor law adherence. HR teams are responsible for understanding and following applicable employment laws, including worker classification rules, wage and hour regulations, and recordkeeping requirements.
• Performance management. Goal setting, ongoing feedback, evaluations, and addressing performance issues in a consistent and documented way are all key to the long-term health of an SMB.
• Employee engagement. HR supports employee engagement by helping foster a positive work environment, encouraging collaboration, resolving conflicts, and ensuring employees feel supported, heard, and motivated.
• Succession planning. This process identifies critical roles within the business and prepares internal or external talent to step into the roles as the company grows or when key team members leave. Even in small businesses, proactive succession planning reduces disruption, preserves institutional knowledge, and supports long-term stability.
• Offboarding. HR oversees resignations and terminations, including final pay, documentation, system access removal, and knowledge transfer.

9 tips and best practices for DIY HR

The DIY HR approach works best when the process and strategy is intentional, structured, and supported by the right expertise. The following discussions can help small businesses manage HR responsibilities more effectively while reducing risk and improving the employee experience.

1. Partner with a freelance HR expert

Even if you manage HR internally, partnering with a freelance human resources manager or HR generalist can significantly strengthen your approach. Freelance HR professionals bring specialized knowledge and real-world experience that many small businesses lack in-house, particularly as regulations and workforce models shift.

By engaging an HR freelancer, small businesses can fill knowledge gaps while maintaining control over day-to-day HR operations. Additionally, outsourcing some HR tasks can free up time for small business owners and leaders to focus on other essential priorities to grow the company. The OnPay survey mentioned earlier found that 70% of small business owners feel they are playing catch-up and could use more time to tackle their to-do lists.

Benefits of partnering with a freelance HR expert include:

• Access to HR expertise without the cost of a full-time hire
• Support with compliance, audits, and policy development
• Guidance during sensitive situations such as terminations or disputes
• Strategic input during periods of growth, restructuring, or expansion
• Flexibility to engage freelancers only when needed

2. Identify your HR needs and goals

HR needs vary depending on team size, growth stage, and industry, among other factors. Before investing time or resources into DIY HR, clearly defining what you want HR to accomplish for your business is important. 

Clarifying goals helps leaders prioritize HR efforts and ensures your DIY approach aligns with broader business strategies.

Business leaders can start by asking questions such as:

• What are the short- and long-term business goals, and how can the workforce support key objectives?
• How much budget is available for hiring and human resources management? 
• Which HR skills exist at the company today and where does the team have gaps? 
• Which HR challenges take up the most time or create the most risk today?
• Which hard and soft skills or roles will the business need in the next six to 12 months?
• What does the job market and competition look like for your immediate open positions? 
• Is the company planning to primarily hire employees, freelancers, or a mix of both?
• Where does the organization need structure versus flexibility in people processes?
• Who will be involved in hiring and other HR decisions? 

3. Understand legal and compliance requirements

Legal compliance is one of the most critical components of HR and one of the biggest risk areas for small businesses. Understanding which regulations apply to your workforce helps protect both the business and team members.

Because regulations vary by location and change over time, small businesses benefit from periodic reviews with an HR or legal expert to ensure continued compliance.

Areas of HR compliance areas to review include:

• Worker classification rules for employees versus independent contractors
• Wage and hour laws, including overtime and minimum wage requirements
• Payroll tax obligations at the federal, state, and local level
• Required workplace policies and postings
• Employee recordkeeping and data privacy requirements

4. Develop standardized HR processes and documentation

Standardized processes bring clarity and consistency to DIY HR. Well-documented HR policies and processes save time, reduce costs, and streamline how organizations manage people, especially as teams grow.

Common HR processes and documentation to standardize include:

• Workplace policies and employee handbooks
• Job descriptions, requirements, and role definitions
• Hiring and interview flowcharts
• Offer letters, employee contracts, and contractor agreements
• Onboarding checklists and new hire documentation
• Performance review templates and goal-setting frameworks
• Offboarding and exit procedures

5. Leverage HR technology

Rather than managing processes and administrative tasks manually, technology helps make DIY HR more scalable and sustainable — especially for lean teams. The right HR solutions and tools can reduce administrative workload, save time, decrease costs, improve accuracy, and create a more consistent experience for both managers and team members at a small business. 

As companies increasingly integrate AI across business functions, more SMBs are relying on AI-powered tools in human resources. In fact, A 2025 survey of 1,100 small business owners and HR professionals distributed by Paychex found that HR is the top business function in which respondents use AI. 

When selecting tools, small businesses should prioritize solutions that integrate well with existing systems and can scale alongside the company.

Examples of HR technology small businesses can leverage include:

• Applicant tracking systems (ATS) such as BambooHR or Teamtailor to manage job postings, applications, and candidate evaluations
• Payroll and tax software like Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll to automate pay, filings, and compliance
• Time tracking tools such as Clockify and My Time to manage time, measure productivity, and ensure accurate payments
• Performance management platforms like Trakstar and Reviewsnap to track goals, reviews, and feedback
• Learning and talent development tools such as EducateMe and TalentLMS to support skill building and training
• Human resources management systems (HRIS) like Deel and Rippling to centralize policies, contracts, and employee records securely

6. Train managers across the business

In a DIY HR model, managers, rather than a dedicated HR leader, often serve as the first point of contact for employees. Providing managers and team leaders with basic HR training helps ensure consistent and compliant people management across the organization. When managers understand their HR responsibilities, issues are more likely to be addressed earlier and more effectively.

Ways to train managers include:

• Sharing written guides on hiring, feedback, and performance management
• Hosting training sessions or workshops on key HR topics
• Conducting performance management-specific training
• Providing scripts or frameworks for difficult conversations
• Offering access to HR freelancers for manager questions or coaching
• Aligning managers on expectations around documentation and decision-making

7. Focus on employee engagement and development

Employee engagement is closely tied to retention, productivity, and overall business performance. Even without a formal HR team, small businesses can create meaningful engagement and development opportunities. 

Investing in development also helps employees feel valued and aligned with the company’s mission.

Ways to support engagement and development include:

• Setting clear goals and expectations for each role
• Offering regular feedback and recognition
• Creating opportunities for skill development or stretch assignments
• Offering access to online learning platforms and development programs 
• Encouraging mentorship or peer learning
• Supporting work-life balance through flexible arrangements

8. Collect and address team member feedback

Feedback provides valuable insight into how HR practices and management decisions impact workers. Regularly collecting feedback helps identify issues early and informs improvements. Addressing feedback builds trust and demonstrates a commitment to continuous improvement.

Actions small businesses can take to gather feedback include:

• Conducting anonymous employee surveys
• Holding regular one-on-one check-ins between individual contributors and managers
• Asking targeted questions during team meetings
• Reviewing feedback shared during performance discussions
• Conducting exit interviews or post-project reviews

9. Identify areas for improvement

DIY HR should be reviewed and refined over time. Tracking key metrics helps small businesses understand what’s working and where adjustments are needed. Many HR software solutions include integrated metrics and insights to help organizations drive ongoing improvements.

Reviewing metrics regularly enables business leaders to make informed decisions, invest resources strategically, and adapt HR practices as the organization grows.

Metrics to track may include:

• Time to hire or time to fill open roles
• Employee turnover or retention rates
• Quality of hires 
• Engagement survey results
• Manager and employee satisfaction scores
• Promotion or internal mobility rates
• Compliance issues or audit findings
• Training participation or skill development progress

Hidden risks and costs of DIY HR

While DIY HR can reduce upfront expenses, the approach can also introduce costly HR issues and risks that small businesses should carefully consider and address.

Risks include: 

• Compliance mistakes. Employment laws are complex and change over time. Misclassifying workers, mishandling payroll, or missing required documentation can result in fines, penalties, or legal disputes, which are often costly and time-consuming to resolve.
• Inconsistent decision-making or processes. Without standardized HR practices, the hiring, promotions, and performance management decisions may vary by manager or situation. This inconsistency can create confusion, reduce trust, and expose the business to claims of unfair treatment.
• Time drain and burnout. Managing HR on top of other responsibilities can quickly become overwhelming. A survey of 386 solopreneurs and 632 small business owners conducted by Adobe found that 40% of entrepreneurs reported burnout as a top concern. Founders and managers may spend significant time on administrative tasks, leading to burnout and pulling focus away from strategy, growth, and core business operations. 
• Lack of HR-specific expertise. HR situations such as terminations, conflicts, or compliance issues often require specialized knowledge. Without access to expertise, small mistakes can escalate into larger challenges.
• Decreased employee engagement. When HR processes are reactive or inconsistent, employees may feel unsupported or disengaged. Over time, this can lead to high turnover, low morale, and reduced productivity.

Implement smarter DIY HR with flexible support from freelancers

When implemented effectively, DIY HR can be a strategic approach for small businesses to build teams, support workers, and achieve goals. By understanding core HR functions, implementing best practices, and addressing common risks, your organization can create a strong HR foundation to drive business growth.

As you implement DIY HR, accessing skilled HR professionals can help your team drive efficiencies and maintain compliance. Upwork simplifies the process of connecting with experienced HR and training freelancers, including recruiting assistants, compensation consultants, HR policies specialists, HRIS specialists, learning and development managers, and employee engagement specialists, who can support recruiting, compliance, policy development, and strategic workforce planning.

Whether you need short-term guidance or ongoing HR support, freelancers can help you to build flexible capabilities without increasing fixed costs or overhead. 

Hire freelancers on Upwork. Or upgrade to a Business Plus plan to reach the top 1% of freelancers on Upwork across multiple categories, and gain exclusive access to talent shortlisting powered by an always-on hiring agent.

Get started today. Log in to your existing account or create an account. 

If you’re a skilled human resources freelancer looking to grow your business, search for jobs on Upwork today.

Upwork is not affiliated with and does not sponsor or endorse any of the tools or services discussed in this article. These tools and services are provided only as potential options, and each reader and company should take the time needed to adequately analyze and determine the tools or services that would best fit their specific needs and situation.

‍

This article is intended for educational purposes and should not be viewed as legal or tax advice. Please consult a professional to find the solution that best fits your situation.